This year's rate rises continued when the big four's increase took effect on Friday 13 November 2026. Our 14 November note covers that rise if repayments already feel tight. The usual advice is to refinance to a cheaper rate. That only helps if another lender approves the loan.
Some borrowers can see a better deal and still cannot get it. They are in what commentators call "mortgage prison": borrowers who could get a better deal elsewhere but no longer pass the eligibility tests for those other loans, even though the refinance would lower their repayments. It was common in 2022-23, when many people could not pass APRA's mandatory 3 percentage point serviceability buffer on the new loan.
Being stuck with your bank is not necessarily permanent. There are still practical steps worth taking, and which of them helps will depend on your situation.
The short version
- Mortgage prison means a cheaper rate exists, but you no longer pass the other lender's eligibility tests.
- The test is the new rate plus a buffer. Once the 13 November rise filters through, Canstar's average rate for a new owner-occupier variable loan is 6.73%: assessed at 9.73% with a 3 percentage point buffer, or 7.73% with a 1 percentage point buffer.
- An older loan shows the gap. Someone who bought about five years ago at an average rate of 2.59% was assessed at 5.59%. Rate rises since October 2021 total 4.75 percentage points. That is when APRA lifted the buffer from 2.5% to 3%.
- Equity is the second gate. Refinancers generally need at least 20% equity, or the new lender will ask them to pay lenders mortgage insurance, which can wipe out the saving.
- Values have slipped: Primara Research estimates the median home has lost about $63,400 in value since the start of the year.
The first trap: the new lender's stress test
When you refinance, the new lender assesses the rate it would charge, plus a buffer. That test is separate from the repayment you make today, and the extra margin is known as the serviceability buffer. Our 8 November note explains how the serviceability buffer works.
Canstar's Sally Tindall, quoted by Tim McIntyre at realestate.com.au on 13 November 2026, says that once the latest hike filters through, an owner-occupier taking out a new variable loan will be looking at an average rate of 6.73%. With the standard 3 percentage point buffer, that means being stress tested at 9.73%. Even with a 1 percentage point buffer, the test is 7.73%.
Tindall says someone who bought five years ago at an average rate of 2.59% was assessed at 5.59%. That 3 percentage point test has been no match for the 4.75 percentage points of rate rises since October 2021, when APRA lifted the buffer from 2.5% to 3%.
People who bought when rates were at record lows, and who borrowed at or near capacity, are especially vulnerable. Tindall said: "Borrowers were trapped in mortgage prison because, when they went to refinance, they couldn't pass their new bank's serviceability test because interest rates had risen so significantly in a short space of time."
The table below sets out that arithmetic. Even a 1 percentage point buffer is still a test, and there is no guarantee a lender will apply a lower buffer to a refinance.
| Borrower | Rate | Buffer | Assessed at |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bought about five years ago | 2.59% | 3 points | 5.59% |
| New variable loan after the 13 November rise (average) | 6.73% | 3 points | 9.73% |
| New variable loan after the 13 November rise (average) | 6.73% | 1 point | 7.73% |
Source: Canstar's Sally Tindall via realestate.com.au, 13 November 2026. The 6.73% rows are Canstar's average rate for a new owner-occupier variable loan once the 13 November rise filters through (new loans, post-hike).
The second trap: falling equity and lenders mortgage insurance
Equity is the second gate. It is measured against current property values. As a general rule, refinancers need at least 20% equity. Below that, the new lender will ask them to pay lenders mortgage insurance. Tindall notes the premium can often wipe out the financial benefit of refinancing. For some borrowers it may still leave them ahead. For others it may not. It depends on your situation.
Prices are on the slide in most capital cities. Someone who previously owned 20% of their property might own a smaller share now, if value has come down by more than the principal repaid. Someone who bought with a very small deposit may take longer than they expected to reach 20%.
Primara Research's Peter Drennan, in HomeLoanRates.com.au analysis reported by Aidan Devine at realestate.com.au on 14 November 2026, estimates the median home has lost about $63,400 in value since the start of the year. That is a market-wide median, not a valuation of your home.
Tindall said: "Newer borrowers are increasingly finding they're in mortgage prison because their equity is on the slide." In general, the people most exposed bought in 2021 or 2022 near their borrowing limit, or with a small deposit. A lender's valuation can differ from an online estimate, and from another lender's valuation.
Buyers are feeling the same squeeze
Drennan says a new buyer who could just afford the median home in January would today be $45,000 short on the same income. The average buyer's borrowing power has fallen 10.5% since the start of the year. He said: "Owners are poorer on paper and buyers are no closer, so the market is falling with no one on the winning side." Refinancers are caught in the same squeeze from the other side: lower values can shrink their equity, while higher rates shrink what a new lender will approve.
Five things you can still do
These are general steps, and none of them is a promise that a lender will agree.
1. Check your real equity before assuming you are under 20%
Get a current valuation or estimate and compare it with the balance you still owe. Lenders' valuations can differ from an estimate, and from each other. Check before you assume you are under 20%, and check before you assume you are clear.
2. Ask your current lender for a better rate
Ask for a retention rate, ideally with a written competing offer. If you cannot leave, your leverage is weaker. Tindall has called that a tough ask, and it still costs nothing to ask. A lower rate with your current lender does not require another lender's stress test. Our 10 November note sets out how to ask your bank for a better rate. No lender has to agree to a retention rate.
3. Improve your serviceability before you apply
In the months before you apply, cancel unused credit cards or cut the limits, pay down small debts, and tidy household spending so your statements match the budget you put forward. The guide to serviceability and HEM sets out how lenders look at living expenses.
4. Ask whether a lender assesses refinances at a lower buffer
Ask whether a refinance is assessed at a lower buffer when the new repayment would be lower. In 2023, Westpac, NAB and ANZ said they would assess some applications at a 1 or 2 percentage point buffer if other key metrics were met. Policies and criteria vary, and they change, so there is no guarantee a lender will use a lower buffer. And even a 1 percentage point buffer on Canstar's 6.73% average for a new variable loan still means a test at 7.73%.
5. Do the lenders mortgage insurance maths over the time you will keep the loan
Compare the one-off lenders mortgage insurance premium, and any switching costs, with the repayment saving over the years you expect to hold the loan. For some borrowers it may still come out ahead. For others it may not. It depends on your situation. The refinance checklist for beginners is a practical way to line those costs up.
When it is worth getting help
Comparing the lenders mortgage insurance cost against the rate saving, and how different lenders treat a refinance, is where a broker can help. Weighing the LMI cost against the rate saving is the core of a refinance review with a mortgage broker, although the final decision always rests with the lender.
Want to talk it through?
A broker at Loanworth can look at your rate, your equity and whether a refinance is realistic for your situation. There is no cost and no pressure.
Related reading
- The rate rise is now live: what to do if repayments feel tight (14 November 2026)
- How to ask your bank for a better rate (10 November 2026)
- How the serviceability buffer works (8 November 2026)
- The refinancing surge, and when cashbacks are worth a closer look (20 October 2026)
Sources: A. Tim McIntyre, "Strict bank stress tests leave mortgage prisoners unable to switch to cheaper home loans", realestate.com.au, 13 November 2026. Mortgage prison: borrowers who could get a better deal elsewhere but no longer pass the eligibility tests for those other loans, even though the refinance would lower their repayments. Common in 2022-23, when many could not pass APRA's mandatory 3 percentage point serviceability buffer on the new loan. Canstar's Sally Tindall: people who bought when rates were at record lows and borrowed at or near capacity are especially vulnerable. Someone who bought five years ago at an average rate of 2.59% was assessed at 5.59%. That 3 percentage point stress test has been no match for the 4.75 percentage points of rate rises since October 2021, when APRA lifted the buffer from 2.5% to 3%. In 2023, major banks including Westpac, NAB and ANZ announced they would assess some loan applications at a buffer of 1 or 2 percentage points instead, as long as the borrower passed other key metrics. Once the latest hike filters through, Canstar's average rate for a new owner-occupier variable loan is 6.73%; with the standard 3 percentage point buffer the assessment rate is 9.73%; with a 1 percentage point buffer, 7.73%. Newer borrowers increasingly find they are in mortgage prison because their equity is on the slide. As a general rule, refinancers need at least 20% equity, otherwise the new lender will ask them to pay lenders mortgage insurance, which can often wipe out the financial benefit of refinancing. Equity is measured against current property values, and prices are on the slide in most capital cities. Some who previously owned 20% of their property might own less now; those who bought with very small deposits may take longer than expected to get over the threshold. Options Tindall described: try to negotiate a better deal with your current bank (a tough ask without leverage if you cannot leave); review finances to improve borrowing capacity (ditch unused credit cards or reduce limits, cut household spending, pay down existing debts); consider paying lenders mortgage insurance if the deal you are refinancing to can still put you ahead. (realestate.com.au). B. Aidan Devine, "Loan barriers wipe out gains from home price falls", realestate.com.au, 14 November 2026, reporting HomeLoanRates.com.au and Primara Research analysis. Primara Research's Peter Drennan: the median home has lost about $63,400 in value since the beginning of the year, but a new buyer who could just afford it in January would today be $45,000 short on the same income. The average buyer's borrowing power has fallen 10.5% since the start of the year. Drennan: "Owners are poorer on paper and buyers are no closer, so the market is falling with no one on the winning side." (realestate.com.au). The big four's increase from Friday 13 November 2026, and how the serviceability buffer works, are drawn from our 14 November note and our 8 November note, and are not re-sourced here.
General information only, not credit advice.
Loanworth Pty Ltd CRN 547934, Connective ACL 389328